AP Voters Defend Controversial Picks in Josh Allen’s Tight NFL MVP Win Over Lamar Jackson
Josh Allen’s victory in the NFL MVP race over Lamar Jackson sparked intense debate, as Associated Press (AP) voters faced scrutiny over their controversial choices. The Buffalo Bills quarterback edged out Jackson in a tight contest, with some voters splitting their selections, leading to what many described as a “split-the-baby” outcome.
A Close and Divisive MVP Race
Throughout the season, Lamar Jackson of the Baltimore Ravens was seen as a frontrunner for the award, leading his team to the AFC’s top seed and demonstrating his elite dual-threat ability. Meanwhile, Josh Allen delivered an exceptional campaign for the Bills, showcasing his versatility as both a passer and rusher. While Jackson’s statistical efficiency and leadership were undeniable, Allen’s individual dominance and impact on Buffalo’s success made him a compelling candidate.
Despite Jackson’s strong resume—including impressive passing numbers, rushing ability, and leading Baltimore to the AFC’s best record—some voters leaned toward Allen’s all-around contributions. The final vote tally reflected a divided electorate, with some voters opting for a split vote rather than awarding the full honor to one candidate.
AP Voters Explain Their Choices
In response to criticism, AP voters defended their selections, citing the difficulty of choosing between two deserving candidates. Some emphasized Allen’s sheer impact on the Bills’ offense, noting that without him, Buffalo’s chances of success would have diminished significantly. Others pointed to Jackson’s efficiency, leadership, and team success as justification for their votes.
One voter explained, “Allen carried the Bills through adversity and put up incredible numbers. While Jackson was fantastic, Allen’s overall contributions were too significant to ignore.” Another countered, stating, “Jackson was the best player on the best team in the AFC. His leadership and ability to change games with his arm and legs made him the clear MVP choice for me.”
Split Voting and the “Compromise” Outcome
The concept of split voting played a crucial role in Allen’s victory. Some voters, unable to choose between the two, divided their votes, leading to a scenario where neither player won decisively. This controversial outcome left many fans questioning the fairness of the MVP selection process, with some arguing that Jackson was more deserving based on team success and efficiency.
Reactions from Fans and Analysts
The response from fans and analysts was mixed. Supporters of Jackson felt he was robbed of a second MVP award, citing his leadership in taking the Ravens to the AFC’s best record. Meanwhile, Bills fans defended Allen’s win, pointing to his statistical dominance and ability to elevate his team in key moments.
NFL analysts also weighed in, with some arguing that the MVP voting process should be re-evaluated to prevent future split decisions. Others defended the AP voters, highlighting the difficulty of choosing between two elite quarterbacks.
Looking Ahead
With the MVP debate settled, both Josh Allen and Lamar Jackson will turn their focus toward their ultimate goal—winning a Super Bowl. Regardless of the voting outcome, their performances this season solidified their status as two of the NFL’s premier quarterbacks.
While Allen’s MVP win may remain a topic of debate, one thing is certain: both he and Jackson delivered MVP-worthy seasons that will be remembered for years to come.
