The Red Sox selected Whitt in the 15th round of the 1972 amateur draft, just ahead of Jason Thompson, a notable first baseman for the Tigers and Dodgers. Due to Carlton Fisk’s presence, Whitt couldn’t break into the Red Sox roster and was left unprotected in the 1976 expansion draft, where we picked him up.
Whitt had 41 at-bats in our inaugural season and appeared in a few games in 1978. In 1979, he spent the entire season in the minors. At 28, he finally secured a role in the majors, serving as the left-handed half of a catching platoon with Rob Davis. He struggled at the plate, hitting .237/.288/.353.
In the strike-shortened 1981 season, the Jays acquired Buck Martinez, who would share catching duties with Whitt for several years. Unfortunately, Whitt’s performance remained underwhelming, with a .236/.307/.297 batting line and just one home run.
In 1982, Bobby Cox became manager, and Cito Gaston became the hitting coach. Ernie found his hitting stroke that year, I’m sure in large part due to Cito, getting his averages up to .261/.307/.440 and suddenly finding home run power-hitting 11 in just 284 at-bats. Ernie bought into the all-out pull philosophy that Cito liked. In 1983, he continued his improvement with the bat, hitting .256/.346/.459 with 17 home runs in just 344 at-bats. Combined with Buck Martinez, the Jays got 27 home runs and 89 RBI out of the catcher platoon. In two seasons, with Cito’s tutoring, Whitt went from 1 homer to 11 to 17.
In 1984, Ernie continued the power-hitting, with 15 homers and 315 at-bats. Then, in our first playoff year, 1985, Whitt set a new career-high for homers with 19 hitting .245/.323/.444 in 412 at-bats, and he made the All-Star team. But Ernie didn’t do well in our seven-game ALCS loss to the Royal. He hit just .190. Whitt started every game of the series against both left-handed and right-handed pitchers. Martinez was injured (likely most of you remember that play where he broke his leg, dislocated his ankle, and still tagged out the runner at home), and Jeff Hearron was the backup catcher for the series.
Whitt remained a reliable player over the years. In 1986, he hit 16 home runs. After Buck Martinez retired before the 1987 season, Charlie Moore joined Whitt as his catching partner. Whitt hit 19 home runs that year, matched his career-high with 75 RBIs, and set personal bests with 24 doubles and 120 hits, batting .269/.334/.455. However, the team collapsed at the end of the season, allowing the Detroit Tigers to overtake them for first place. Whitt missed the final games due to a rib injury, and his presence might have secured them the top spot.
In 1988, he maintained his solid performance, hitting .251/.348/.410 with 16 home runs in 398 at-bats. The Jays reached the playoffs again in 1989, with Whitt contributing a .262/.349/.416 batting line and 11 home runs in 385 at-bats. Unfortunately, he struggled in the ALCS against the Oakland A’s, hitting just .125 with 1 home run in 16 at-bats as the team lost the series in five games.
After the season, Ernie was traded to Atlanta with Kevin Batiste for Rick Trlicek to clear space at catcher for Pat Borders and Greg Myers. He played in Atlanta for one year, then for Baltimore for part of 1991, and his playing career was over. Whitt had a terrific career for a guy who only got into 33 games before his 28th birthday. Ernie only had 300 at-bats in a season when he was 31. Yet, he was amazingly consistent; from 1983 to 1989, he had OPS+ numbers ranging from 104 to 121, on-base % from .323 to .349, and slugging averages from .410 to .459.
He played 1328 games over 15 seasons and hit 134 home runs. He finished up with a .248/.324/.410 and 534 RBI and was an excellent defensive catcher with a decent arm. Our first manager, Roy Hartsfield, didn’t think Whitt could make it as a major leaguer. Whitt proved him wrong. He had the longest career with the Jays of any player who played in our first season.
Whitt was a favourite of mine. I loved his all-out pull swing (Cito got a lot of batters to go to an all-out pull swing, but Whitt was the most fun to watch). He would often end his swing on his left knee and swing right off his feet. You would have sworn he couldn’t have hit the ball if you watched him swing. His back knee would drop and drag on the ground, which should have caused his bat to fall, and he should have swung under the ball. But he had such an open stance that he could see the ball well and was brilliant. He was a catcher, and he was a guess hitter. And as a catcher, he was a very good guesser. So fool him; he’ll miss the ball, but he didn’t fool easy.
He wrote a biography called ‘Catch: A Major League Life’ (which I have somewhere around the house). One of the controversial things he said in the book was that umpire Joe Brinkman was ‘incompetent’. Another thing he said in his book was that he shouldn’t have been just a platoon catcher. In that, he was wrong. He hit just .223/.303/.311 against left-handed pitchers.
In his book “Big Book of Baseball Lineups,” Rob Neyer has Whitt as our all-time best catcher, and I still agree. He also says Whitt played the best defense of any catcher we had. In his “New Historical Baseball Abstract,” Bill James has Whitt ranked as the 72nd-best catcher of all time. Whitt would be moved down a few spots since the book was published. He was arguably the most popular player among Jay fans when he was with Toronto. He played the game hard and did a ton of charity work during his off-field hours.
Ernie was the Jays’ bench coach, then the first base coach starting in 2005, and was fired with John Gibbons and most of the coaching staff in June of 2008. Whitt burned bridges behind him by ripping JP Ricciardi and calling himself the ‘best manager the Jay’s never had. Maybe he would have been good.
Whitt has managed the Canadian National Baseball Team since 2004 and managed Canada in the Olympic qualifier. He is in the Canadian Baseball Hall of Fame.
I’m likely the only one who thought this, but when Buck Martinez had to leave the broadcast booth this year, it would have been fitting to have Whitt replace him. But I have no idea if he could do the job.
Whitt based everything on his ability. You have to admire someone like that. He wasn’t a prospect in the minors and didn’t show power until he was in his 30s.
Ernie Whitt is married and has three children.
Whitt is near the top of my favourite former Blue Jays list. Being a lefty hitter, I often tried to copy swing, but without the great result. I could never get the level swing while dropping down nearly to my knee. I loved watching him swing the bat.
Happy Birthday, Ernie. I hope it is a good one.
Here is a video of Ernie’s swing.
