Lionel Messi’s nomination for the 2023 MLS MVP award has sparked an interesting debate among soccer fans and experts alike. On one hand, his arrival at Inter Miami has undoubtedly elevated the team’s profile and performance, creating a buzz around both the league and the club. On the other hand, questions arise about whether Messi’s limited appearances in MLS should merit such a prestigious accolade. Our writers examine both sides of the debate.
Messi’s impact on Inter Miami has been profound since his midseason arrival. The Argentine superstar has scored several crucial goals, helping Miami make a late push for a playoff spot and bringing newfound excitement to Major League Soccer. His presence on the field has transformed Miami from a struggling team to one capable of competing with the best in the league. In addition, Messi’s leadership and playmaking ability have elevated his teammates’ performances, making them a more cohesive and dangerous unit.
However, the biggest argument against Messi’s MVP candidacy is his limited time in the league. He joined Inter Miami in July, meaning he played far fewer games than most other MVP candidates, many of whom have been contributing to their teams throughout the entire season. Critics argue that awarding the MVP to a player who has only been present for a portion of the campaign undermines the efforts of players who have consistently performed over the long haul.
Another point of contention is the fact that Messi’s best performances have come in the Leagues Cup, a tournament separate from MLS. While his brilliance in that competition brought Miami its first-ever trophy, it’s worth considering whether his impact in MLS regular season matches alone is enough to justify the MVP nod. Messi’s contributions in domestic league games, while significant, haven’t been as statistically dominant as those of some other candidates.
Ultimately, the decision boils down to how the voters interpret the meaning of “Most Valuable Player.” If the award is based on a player’s overall impact on the league, both on and off the pitch, Messi is a strong contender. But if it’s based purely on contributions during the regular season, his case becomes less convincing compared to players who have played a full season at a high level.
In the end, while Messi’s influence is undeniable, whether he truly deserves the MVP title in MLS remains a topic of heate
d debate.
